Tasting Video #44

May 14, 2025 |

In this episode I taste both of Grandma’s tiny bottles of Monnet Cognac (#79 and #116) with Christine Cooney, co-owner of Heavenly Spirits Imports (and a French knight!). Heavenly Spirits is the US importer for Monnet Cognac today. We compare the two tiny bottles and look for bottle-to-bottle variation, then taste the modern “Sunshine” bottling that matches up best to Grandma’s bottles. Christine was a delightful and knowledgeable guest (with a very charming French accent) and we had an awesome time comparing and contrasting.

Prefer to read than watch? Check out the transcript under the video. Prefer to listen? Look for My Tiny Bottles wherever you get your podcasts!

TRANSCRIPT

Teaser

Tammy: So what are we looking for when we’re tasting a Cognac?

After Opening Credits

Tammy: Hello and welcome to My Tiny Bottles, the project where I’m exploring my grandmother’s legacy of miniature liquor bottles one tiny bottle at a time. I’m your host, Tammy Coxen, and I’m here today at Heavenly Spirits with Christine Cooney. Christine, why don’t you introduce yourself?

Christine: Okay, well, before I get too involved, I was born and raised in the beautiful region of Cognac, therefore my accent.

Tammy, laughing: We would never have noticed.

Christine: No, you’re so nice. Yes, thank you, but no, I do.

Christine: My grandfather had a farm. He was a winemaker and he was also making plum brandy in his spare time from the plums that we harvested on the farm. And when I had the ripe age of six, actually, he told me it’s time to taste brandy. And I said, okay. So we did. And he started me off with his own brandy, plum brandy, that was probably close to 140 proof.

Christine: And of course, as a result, I really hated it. And then he moved me on to a brown libation that he told me was an Armagnac. And I said, I hate to say it, but I actually didn’t mind it. It was pretty good, even though I was six. And then that’s it. And sometimes I like to think that he put in my mind, in my brain, he planted in the seeds of maybe what it would be like to have a career in the wine and spirit business.

Christine: And there you go. 35 years ago, I got my first job, or maybe more, I don’t know, I can’t count anymore. I got my first job, coincidentally, for a Cognac company. And so there you go. I was back into where I was meant to be, I guess. And since then, for the past 35 years plus, plus I’ve been working in the US mostly for promoting wine and spirits, and all along assembling a portfolio of French artisanal spirits. And that was really cool. My husband Dan, who is a professor by trade and an artist, also supported my love for spirits. And in 2008 we founded Heavenly Spirits, importer of exceptional French spirits. And we are based out of Boston. We import, we have a small portfolio of about 20 brands and those are all made by, you know, family producers who produce anywhere from 5,000 to 250,000 bottles. That’s what we call the genuine craft spirits. The genuine craft spirits. I’m insisting on that.

Tammy: And that’s your specialty.

Christine: And that’s our specialty.

Tammy: Now I Think the bottle that I have for you today probably is a little bit bigger than your specialization. Would that be true? [Note from Tammy: Back in the Monnet’s past they were a bigger producer, but modern Monnet is smaller.] You’re going to taste some Monnet Cognac. So I’ve actually found now two bottles of this in grandma’s collection. So it’s not as big as one of the big four Cognac producers, which I’ve talked about before, but for a time was one of the bestselling brands in the United States and around the world.

Tammy: And these bottles, I think come from 1986 to 2004 is kind of the tightest we’ve been able to pin that down. So before your importing business. Were you aware of Monnet back then?

Christine: Actually, I wasn’t aware of Monnet. Our son Austin, who is also in the business, brought it to us. And even though we were not really looking for another Cognac because we already have three in our portfolio, we love the history and that’s really what did it to us. Of course, the taste. That’s of course the first thing on our list.

Christine: But the history was so rich. It’s a very tumultuous, as you know, because you do more, you know more about Monnet than I do at this point. You’ve done so much research. It’s a very rich history that I don’t think any other Cognac company can really compare to.

Tammy: Yeah, in my story about this, I talk about if Monnet Cognac didn’t exist, then there might not be a European Union. So click the link to watch that previous episode and really dive into just some of the pieces of this really complex and historical brand. But I think we should just dive into the bottle, what do you think?

Christine: Absolutely. So how do you want to do that? You want to taste yours and then compare with….

Tammy: Yes, we’ll taste mine. And then I think we were going to compare with the…. Tammy points to a range of full bottles next to Christine. Which one?

Christine: The VS. The VS and the Sunshine.

Tammy: The Sunshine.

Christine: Because it looks like yours is right in between.

Tammy: Yes.

Christine: In terms of age.

Tammy: Right. So this is a four star. Usually when we think of Cognac, we see three stars or five stars or VS or VSOP. This is somewhere in the middle. And we think that this one (Tammy motions to the Sunshine bottle) is probably also somewhere in the middle. All right, let’s see if I can get this bottle open. That’s often the trickiest part.

Tammy gets the top off and pours samples.

Tammy: We’ll taste this one first and then we’ll come back and do a little side by side there. So. And I actually have two bottles of this. So I’m kind of curious if there’s going to be any bottle variation. So we might crack open the second one and compare. So what are we looking for when we’re tasting a Cognac? Or first smell or looking at a Cognac, what are we looking for?

They start sniffing as they talk.

Christine: Well, it depends how proficient we are. You know, I mean, I guess you would be looking for different things depending if you’re a consumer or if you’re a professional. But of course, the nose is the first indication of what’s in the glass. It’s always very interesting because the nose can reveal some sweetness, can reveal some wood, can reveal some vanilla. We are not sure exactly what this one will reveal because we have never tasted it, so it’s interesting.

Tammy: And I know Monnet’s signature line sort of was sunshine in a glass. Right. So you see the art back there, (Tammy motions to a famous Monnet poster hanging behind them) it was described as a sunny Cognac. So what does that mean?

Christine: Well, a sunny Cognac is something. A Cognac that is bright, easy to drink… (She pauses to nose the glass again.) Sunny.

Tammy: So what are you picking up on the nose here?

Christine: Well, I’m picking up a bit of sweetness. I’m picking vanilla, which are kind of common. I mean, this is very much a Cognac. Let’s not forget we’re also tasting something that is from the Fin Bois area and the Fin Bois area, which is the fourth district in, the fourth appellation in Cognac, is known to produce eau de vies that are very round, very easy to drink, very sunny, like the owner or the initial founder would call it.

Tammy takes a sniff

Tammy: I’m getting light fruit. I’ve tasted another Cognac recently that was just very fruity on the nose. This is less of that. More light fruit. I would say almost a little bit of a floral something or other.

Christine: Yeah. Which is normal because it is a fairly young eau de vie. So it’s normal to find the floral side of it. Like, you know, what do you call lemon tree bloom?

Tammy: Lemon blossom.

Christin: Lemon blossoms, yes. Thank you.

Tammy: Anything you would notice about this one.

Christine: Definitely flower, but also a touch of vanilla. It’s really there. And that’s very typical because they have to be in wood for at least three years, maybe four on this one, but three and a half or something like that. And don’t forget that Cru Fin Bois is not far. And especially the vineyard of Monnet is not far from the Grande Champagne and the Petite Champagne. (Map of Cognac appelations)

Christine: It’s really very close. You go on the freeway, you’re in the Petite Champagne, and you see the Monnet vineyard, and you say “Oh, wow, okay, I didn’t realize that was so close.” So it has an influence on the terroir from the Grande Champagne, Petite Champagne. And that’s why it’s a very rich product.

Christine: This smells delicious.

Tammy: All right, let’s taste this.

They clink glasses and taste.

Christine: Okay, so my first impression, it’s a little less sweet than it smells.

Tammy: Yes, I would agree.

Christine: I’m a little surprised by that.

Tammy: I did expect more obvious vanilla, rounded sweetness on the palate. It’s definitely dry.

Christine: Yeah, definitely more dry.

Tammy: Yeah.

Christine: Interesting, because it does smell like sweet.

Tammy: It does. That’s really interesting. Which I guess just goes to show us how much we associate vanilla with sweet. But, it doesn’t have to be sweet.

Christine: No, no. It is a little bit dry. I think over the years, they, you know, they probably changed the recipe a bit. It’s normal, you know.

Tammy: Well, and that’s always the fun here, right? Where we can compare what was it like before and what is it like now.

Christine: And don’t forget, as you know, this house went through many, many different ownerships, and the last one being Hennessy. And, you know, they depleted the inventory, the stocks of Monnet, and they left them basically with whatever they didn’t want. And so Monnet had to, for the past 15 years, Monnet had to rebuild their inventory of end stocks. But now they have a good size inventory, I can tell you that. It’s interesting to see the… I know there will be a difference. You will surprise. You will be definitely surprised.

Tammy: Well, this is my first sip of the day, so I am taking another sip now to really kind of taste things. I learned this with Scotch. You know, the first sip, you don’t really taste it. You gotta wake up your palate. So I’m diving back in. I mean, I think we were a little, like, startled by it, but I don’t dislike it.

Tammy: It just. The nose led me to think it was going to be sweet, and it is not. It’s a drier Cognac. I could really see mixing with this because it wouldn’t be as sweet in a cocktail context. I’m getting a little bit more sweet and roundness on my second sip.

Christine: Yeah. But it has that peppery finish that is kind of biting you. You know, we say in French, we say “c’est pique.”

Tammy: And is that… So for me, as a cocktail person, my favorite whiskey is rye whiskey, which has that peppery bite. And I think that’s actually what I’m grooving on here and going, oh, yeah, this would be a great cocktail Cognac. I could make like a Manhattan style cocktail with this because it has that dryness and it has that spice. Totally not what I expected.

Christine: Yeah.

Tammy: All right, should we crack the other bottle and see if it’s any different?

Christine: Sure.

Tammy: All right.

Christine: So the Sunshine you want, right? Oh, this other bottle, (she indicates the second mini bottle). I mean, my feeling is that they should taste the same?

Tammy: They SHOULD, but that’s what’s going to be interesting. Tammy picks up the bottle to open it. Uh oh, now we’re getting into the…

Christine: The hard one.

Tammy: Yeah. (Tammy pulls out a grippy jar opening pad.) But I acquired a tool! Followers of the show will know that this is usually a much more traumatic situation when I can’t get into something. Tammy opens the bottle easily and starts pouring samples from the second tiny bottle) All right, we’ll just use this glass and then we can rinse.

Christine: Do you know they came from the same store?

Tammy: I have no idea.

Christine: This one has a price on it.

Tammy: It does have a price on it. Grandma collected over a long period of time, so she collected from the late 70s to the early 2000s. Theoretically, these could have come from the one from the beginning, and one from the end of the time that this was available. I don’t know. (She holds the pair of bottles up to Christine.) To me, they look exactly identical except for the price tag. So I have no idea. All right, let’s see if we notice any difference. I’m just curious. It’s rare that I have two bottles to taste at the same time.

They smell the new sample.

Christine: Funny, I don’t have much nose in this.

Tammy: Yeah, not much.

Christine: Did you notice that too? It’s really strange

Tammy: And did we talk a while while we had the other one poured? And so this one just needs some air?

They taste.

Christine: Now, this one doesn’t have that high peppery finish as much as much. It feels like it lost some of its alcohol, actually.

Tammy: And there was one that. I think this one was slightly lower in volume than the other one.

Christine: That’s interesting.

Tammy: Yeah, it’s not as, not as full bodied.

Christine: But the nose is…

Tammy: They’re pretty close.

Christine: …the nose is different.

Tammy: If I go right side by side…

Christine: Yeah.

Tammy: I would say that they’re pretty close. (Tammy combines her two samples into one glass.)

Christine: Even if they were not from the same batch, they probably were about the same recipe because it is from the same era, really.

Tammy: Right.

Christine: Okay. And don’t forget, I mean, you know, Monnet, while they were moving from one house to another house, they didn’t have vineyard. They only got vineyards a few years ago.

Tammy: Right. And that’s typical for a lot of Cognac makers. I know you tend to work with the small producers who are both growing the grapes and making the brandy. But I know the big houses are all negociants, basically buying up pre-made brandy and then aging it and blending it and… I know there’s a lot of art to a great Cognac, but it is fun that you get to kind of see the terroir play through more directly in a single brand.

Christine: Absolutely.

Tammy: All right, so shall we compare? I think we’re going to compare to the Sunshine, right?

Christine shuffles her glasses around to make space for the new sample.

Christine: Let me move them in order so we know what they are.

Tammy: I just combined. You want to see how those…

Christine: Well, yeah, I might. That’s sometimes how they change, you know.

Tammy: Yeah, that has definitely been one of the things that I’ve discovered is that these do really change after I’ve had them open. I think sometimes with the tiny bottles, you know, they’ve been cooped up for a while.

Christine: Yeah. I mean, at least they don’t have a cork. So they. It doesn’t matter how they stored really.

Tammy: Right. Although some of them leak, you know, and evaporate. There’s definitely been a challenge with that. Okay, so tell me about this. This is the Sunshine bottling.

Tammy pours samples of the Sunshine bottle of modern Monnet from a full size bottle.

Christine: So this is the Sunshine bottling. This is actually a quality that is between a VS and a VSOP. It’s very unusual for a company, for a producer to have something between VS and VSOP because VS and VSOP are the two entrants and then you have the XO.

Tammy: Right.

Christine: But between VS and VSOP. And that’s why now we’re kind of discussing whether or not we’re going to continue this quality. I love the name Sunshine because that really reflects what the initial founder had in mind when he created his Cognac. He said, I want something sunny, bright and easy to drink.

Tammy: And it’s funny because of course we’re talking about sunshine. So I pick this up and I go, this smells like sunshine. But it really does have almost like a citrusy character that I think of as bright, right? Like, it has this kind of brightness to it.

Christine: Absolutely. Because.

Tammy: Yeah.

Christine: And also from a marketing point of view, like my husband would probably say, you know, sunny sunshine is a positive vibe, and people like to hear something that sounds like sunshine. And so from a marketing point of view, we want to keep that name on the bottles.

Tammy: This is very different nose. The Sunshine is much brighter. Alcohol is very present. You know, I’m getting that bite in my nose, I can definitely smell the booziness. But it has this really, this really bright character to it. Less vanilla. Yeah. This really kind of… yeah… I want to say, is it…  I think I have your orange blossoms in mind.

Christine: Yeah, I influenced you. See, that’s the problem.

Tammy: But I think for some people, that’s actually a really good tool because someone who tastes spirits professionally, you know, you have probably worked to develop a vocabulary for how things smell and how things taste.

Christine: Yeah.

Tammy: Most people do not go around sniffing orange blossom and creating a scent memory of that. Or sniffing raspberries and creates a scent memory of that. And so when someone else says, this smells like raspberry, you go, “Oh, actually, okay, I see what you’re saying.” All right.

They taste.

Christine: That is normal. I mean, fresh spring blossoms are very typical to Cognac. Young Cognacs, you know

Tammy: That’s delightful. Definitely less of that peppery finish.

Christine: But we have more of the citrus.

Tammy: Yes, more citrus.

Christine: Definitely more, for sure.

Tammy: More citrus, very specifically. Tammy motions to the tiny bottles. There wasn’t… I don’t think either of us mentioned citrus, except a little bit, perhaps in the nose. But really it was more of a floral nose rather than a citrus nose. This definitely has kind of a citrusy, almost like a little bit of an orange peel kind of note.

Christine: That’s very bright. Very.

Tammy: I could mix with this in a cocktail, too, but I would do something very different with it than I would the other. This would be really good in a Sidecar where we’d have the orange liqueur to kind of play off of it and amplify that brightness.

Christine: You’re the expert on that

Tammy: All right, well, that was, that’s a really interesting comparison. So this… (Tammy indicates the big bottle) The Sunshine is really delightful.

Christine: Yes. And again, that was what the founder wanted. JG Monnet. He said, “A tasting of Monnet Cognac should be a moment of refinement and pleasure.” And that’s what I think the company is trying to keep on that, you know, and we certainly encourage them to keep that feel and that identity of a brand for a brand, you know?

Tammy: Yeah. So anything else you’d like to tell people about Cognac, about Monnet, about Heavenly Spirits?

Christine: Well, you know, we started to import Monnet again. It was brought to us by our son, older son, Austin, and he, at the time was working for Monnet. And we really had to take two looks at that, because even though we were not looking, we actually decided to take the brand on because it was a very solid brand in terms of taste and presentation and feel and identity.

Christine: And we felt like it would… The history itself was to mind. I had no idea that Jean Monnet was the architect of the EU. I’m like, “I’m French, I should know that, right?” I’m like, “Okay, let me go to my history and look further.” Until then, I was discovering a world of information.

Christine: And then we got in touch with Jean Monnet’s grandson, and he’s actually very active in promoting Jean Monnet. And they have a Jean Monnet website and everything, all the work he did and everything. And it’s fascinating to see how things like that happen. So we took the brand on, and unfortunately, it was during COVID so it was a slow start. And of course, last year, the Cognac business has started to be a bit more difficult in general.

Tammy: I think all spirits categories right now are struggling a little bit.

Christine: But Cognac has been hard hit, and it’s becoming a bit difficult for us to try to compete in a very competitive market. And, of course, the tariff situation is not helping at all. But we’ll get out of this. We will. We will. And as long as we have good products, I believe that we will be doing fine.

Tammy: And I think, like, if you look at the arc of history, you know, Cognac’s popular, and then it goes away a little, and then it comes back, and then it goes away. You know, it’s always this, this ebb and flow through time as different things fall in and out of favor. But I am really thrilled to have been introduced to this modern version of this older bottle, which I could definitely see adding to my repertoire, because this (indicating the modern sample) is truly delicious. They’re both good, but this is definitely really nice.

Christine: See, you lose the pepper.

Tammy: Yeah, you lose the pepper.

Christine: You lose the pepper, you gain

Tammy: You get the citrus.

Christine: Yeah.

Tammy: Yep.

Christine: And it’s bright. It makes it bright.

Tammy: So, yeah. (Tammy motions to the modern bottle sample) Sidecars. (Tammy motions to the tiny bottle sample) Manhattans. There we go. All right. Where can people find you online?

Christine: Well, that’s a good question. Well, we started last year an e commerce platform and it turned out that we didn’t seem to have the right partners. So that is kind of an evolving situation that we’re trying to fix. On the website we have a Where to Buy page and depending on the state where you come from, you can probably find at least a few stores in all the states that we sell to currently. Even though our company wide sells into about 38 states, we have Monnet in about 18 right now.

Tammy: 18 states. Okay.

Christine: So it’s just a matter of you know, going to our website, going that big map, zooming on the state that you’re in and trying to find it. If not call us.

Tammy: And your website is…

Christine: heavenlyspirits.com

Tammy: And we will put a link to that in the show notes. And I imagine they also have an Instagram and other online presences. I’ll put links in there so you know how to find this stuff.
https://www.instagram.com/heavenlyspirits/
https://www.facebook.com/HeavenlySpiritsImports
https://bsky.app/profile/heavenlyspirits.bsky.social 

Tammy: You can of course find me at mytinybottles.com, you can find me on Bluesky as @tammylc, you can find me on Instagram and Facebook as @mytinybottles. And please give a like, give a share. Give us a subscribe. If you like Cognac, if you’re familiar with Monnet or this is new to you tell us about what you think and would love to hear from you in all of those places.

Tammy: Cheers.

They toast.

Christine: Cheers. Thank you Tammy for having us.

Tammy: Thank you so much.

Christine: It was a pleasure.

Tammy: Thank you for having me here.

Want even more My Tiny Bottles? Patreon supporters get access to bonus content, behind the scenes information, monthly cocktail recipes and more. Become a free member or paid supporter here!

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *